New! The Reformulated Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks

Mally Evercolor Shadow Stick

Press Sample


Reformulations. They can either have you jumping for joy or shaking your head in bewilderment. As a fan of Mally Beauty, I’ve always been extremely impressed with each product I’ve tried. And I wondered if the reformulated Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks, $25, could live up to the quality of the original.

Would the shadow sticks work even better? Would the reformulation make any difference? Would I wish I had hoarded the old sticks?

First, I’m curious as to the reason behind the change. According to the limited information I received, the reformulation was meant to provide more hydration. This would also mean the sticks would have additional anti-aging benefits. If my eye makeup can keep my eyes feeling hydrated and looking younger, I’m on board.

As much as I love the new addition to the formulation, would it have any affect on the smudge-proof, transfer-proof, crease-proof or bullet-proof qualities of the Evercolor Shadow Sticks? I’m happy to report, it had no effect. These shadows still perform beautifully. The only change is that instead of having 45 seconds of playtime to blend or blur, you now have only 30 seconds before the color is locked in place.

Mally Shadow Stick Swatch

Out of the ten shadows in the collection, I was sent two to review, Shimmering Mauve and Champagne. Champagne is a shimmery pale gold while Shimmering Mauve is a shimmery bronze. They both glide on like butter and are easy to build or smudge out. They also have great lasting power and don’t crease or transfer, with or without primer.

Of the two colors, I would say Champagne is my favorite. I like how I can quickly run it over my lids or in my inner corners to brighten my eyes, especially on more minimal or natural makeup days.

I was curious to see what the other shadows in the line looked like, since both Shimmering Mauve and Champagne have shimmer in their formulation. I couldn’t really find anything online, so I visited my local Ulta. I stealthily took a picture of the display on my phone and swatched a few of the other shades. It does seem that the other shadows in the collection also have some type of shimmer to them, but nothing too overpowering.

Mally Ulta DisplayMally Ulta Swatches

Overall: The newly reformulated Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks, $25, is an improvement on the old formulation. The shadows are creamy, long-lasting, and easy to use. They keep your eyes feeling hydrated, without any irritation. They are definitely worth checking out, even at $25 a piece. My only complaint is with the packaging, for the price, it feels a bit cheap. I prefer the old packaging, which felt more substantial and didn’t show every little finger print like the new chrome look.

Have you tried the new Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks?

  • TheNewClassy

    Let’s see. I think I like the Mauve a little better. That would be more my tone. Either one looks great though!

  • TheNewClassy

    These are some really gorgeous colors. I might have to try some of these out for spring! Thanks!

  • Julie

    I always get scared when companies change a product that I love! I’ve never a shadow stick before, but I’ll have to pick one of these up.

    • These are great and the formulation still is on point.

  • I picked up the new Mally set from QVC, and it had two of the shadow sticks – Moonlight and Quartz. I didn’t even realize they were a new formulation! I only swatched them on my hand, though – very shimmery, also, but I like that. I thought the chrome packaging was just something for this set. Good to know!

    • I like the shimmer as well. It is a bit unexpected.

  • These do not budge!

  • I don’t really use eyeshadow pens or sticks, but it’s definitely convenient and efficient. The colors are nice and I’m glad they improved the quality of their product.

    • The reformulation is a nice improvement on a great product.

  • I didn’t knwo they made these changes. They’re very pretty and it’s nice that they’re so long-lasting.

    • They really didn’t make a huge deal about the changes either.

  • Debra Hawkins

    These are so pretty! I love the little bit of shimmer in them. So gorgeous!

    • I really like the bit shimmer as well.

  • marciaf

    I like the ones I reviewed so much that I bought Pink Champagne to add to my collection. These wear beautifully.

  • Michele

    I love makeup that actually lasts a long time! Going to have to try this out! 🙂

    • I was extremely impressed by their staying power.

  • I have never tried them and to be honest don’t wear anyone else’s makeup besides M.A.C. I tend to stick with what I know works for me but these colors are beautiful!

    • Mally makes a lot of great products.

  • Betzy Carmona

    The color are pretty

  • Nicole Cochingco Escat

    Well, it actually look like a good product to try. I love the colors that’s why i want to try it.

    • They do have a lot of great colors to try.

  • These seems like something worth trying. Too bad Mally products aren’t sold here where I live.

  • Nikki

    Never tried that before. That looks really amazing. I would love to try that.

    • Hope you enjoy if you do try it out.

  • wendy

    I never tried this line before. It looks like a great product! Thank you for sharing!

    • They have a lot of great products.

  • The champagne and mauve eyeshadow sticks are gorgeous. I love how shimmery they are and I have never heard of the brand before so thank you for spotlighting it!

  • Aziel Morte

    Looks like a great product and the colors was beautiful

    • I really like the color selection.

  • OnceUponADollhouse

    WOW. These colors look amazing. Glitter is the best. We’ve never tried this brand before.

    • I would highly recommend checking Mally out.

  • Shadow sticks are my favorite!! I used to use those back in the day! These colors looks so rich and beautiful!

    • They are so easy to use, I can see why they would be favs.

  • Shannon Graham

    As a young woman, I never gave hydration a second thought. Now that I am older, suddenly it becomes more of an important feature. Thanks for sharing.

  • CourtneyLynne Storms

    omg these eye shadow sticks sound pretty fabulous!!!! I definitely need to get myself some!!!

  • Sounds like a good product and amazing brand to try. Love it!

  • I’m not makeup savvy, but this sounds like a great product. Love the colors!

    • Shadow sticks are perfect for every skill level.

  • mail4rosey

    I like that they guide on so smoothly. I’ve never tried shadow in a stick, but I’m game!

  • Norah Salazar

    I am a huge Mally fan, she has a lot of amazing products, and these sticks is one of them, glad to hear they are as good as ever!

  • I’ve never tried Mally before! That plum shade is gorgeous.

  • Aleya Bamdad

    I’ve never tried a shadow stick before but I would love to try out the two colors that they sent you- especially if they’re this easy to use.

  • These shadow sticks look really easy to use. I’ve been trying to step up my eye makeup game so I think these would really make my life easier.

  • Lisa Rios

    Mally sounds like a pretty new brand for me but these shadow sticks looks good & I love that they have 10 different shadows to try out. I would love the Champagne & the Royal Plum out of these.

  • Stacy

    Love the shades! Never tried them before. Thanks for the information! I need to check them out.

  • Camesha

    Very pretty colors The royal plum is my fave. I’ve heard good things about Mally Makeup.